Rules were the only major record type with no vector, so `search` could never
return one and a rule could arrive only by being preloaded. That single fact is
what made every rule compete for one always-on budget.
THE DECISION THE TASK ASKED FOR, made explicitly: a sibling rule_embeddings
table, not a polymorphic embedding row. The ROW could have been generalised;
the SEARCH could not. semantic_search_notes is Note-specific scoping end to end
— the visibility clause, the supersession penalty, note_type/task_kind/system
filters — and a rule shares none of it, scoping instead by rulebook ownership
or project. Generalising the row while still needing two searches is the worst
of both: a key with referential integrity to neither table, on the path every
session start runs, to share four columns. What is genuinely common is
BEHAVIOUR — get_embedding, chunk_document, embedding_text, CHUNKER_VERSION —
and those are reused as-is. Sharing them is the DRY win; sharing the table
would have been the DRY costume.
The document shape is measured, not chosen (note 2485). That pass found the
snippet was the only discriminative record in the corpus — a 0.153
top-to-second gap against 0.010-0.023 — and that the cause was its SHAPE:
purpose stated twice in a short single-topic document. rule_document
reproduces it: the trigger in the title AND as the body's first line.
And it excludes `why`, which matters more than any of it. `why` is dated
incident narrative — rule 46's runs to 4,300 characters — and long multi-topic
prose is exactly what made sixteen dev-logs mutually indistinguishable. Adding
it would not give the vector more to work with; it would give every rule the
SAME thing to work with. rule_document takes no `why` parameter at all, so a
well-meaning caller cannot pass one.
A rule with no trigger degrades to title + statement — findable, less sharp.
That is an argument for backfilling triggers (step 6), not for padding the
document with whatever text is nearby.
search(content_type="rule") returns the rule WITH its why and how_to_apply:
they are its operational half, the session payload never carries them, and a
caller who went looking should not have to re-fetch. Writes re-index
fire-and-forget like notes; startup backfills in its own try block so neither
backfill can skip the other. rule_embeddings is derived, so it joins
note_embeddings in the backup's explicitly-NOT-included list.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
