feat(rules): a surfaced rule gets an outcome, not just a read (#4212)

Milestone 419 step 1. `rule_usage_events` could say a rule was SURFACED and
that it was PULLED. It could not say what happened next, so a rule that fires
constantly and is always obeyed and a rule that fires constantly and is never
obeyed left byte-identical telemetry. The second is far the more urgent and
was the one the readout could not name — measured on a session where three of
seven misses were caught by the operator and none by the system.

Two new events, `applied` and `departed`, and a `detail` column carrying the
why of a departure. No CHECK migration: `event` was created in 0094 as plain
Text with no constraint, verified in the migration rather than assumed from
the model, so rule 36 does not bite here — said in both places because the
next person adding a value will reach for it.

THE THIRD STATE IS DERIVED, AND THAT IS THE DESIGN. Read-and-silently-
unchanged is the failure this milestone was opened on, and it cannot be
reported: an agent that knew it was ignoring a rule would not be ignoring it.
So nothing here asks. `applied` and `departed` are reported; the third state
is a rule that was opened and left no trace. An `ignored` enum member would
collect nothing while reading as though it had measured something, which is
#3311's failure — a statistic that could not vary being taken for a finding.

`detail` is a column rather than two more bare event strings because a
departure stripped of its reason reads back as a miss, so the two states this
exists to separate would collapse again one layer down, in the readout, where
nobody would see it happen. Nullable: following a rule needs no argument, and
an expensive event is one that stops being recorded.

`outcome_state` is the single reading of the four states, taking the aggregate
`usage_for_rules` already returns, so the badge, the readout and any later
session summary cannot disagree about what "followed" means — the drift #3246
found across the rules system. A departure outranks an application: a rule
both applied and argued with is a rule someone argued with, and the argument
is the half worth surfacing.

`rule_outcome` is the MCP door, classed as a WRITE. The read-only set
tolerates getters that call record_pulled, but those are reads that leave a
trace; this tool's entire effect is the row, and the row carries prose the
agent authored. A read-scoped key that can put text in the operator's
database is not read-scoped, whatever table it lands in.

Backup carries `detail` on both sides. It is the one field here a fresh
install cannot re-earn — counts come back by being used again, a stated
reason exists once — and #4197 records that the column guard watches the
export side only, so the round-trip test is the thing that would catch a
one-sided add.

Delivery is deliberately not settled here: how an agent gets prompted to
record an outcome is step 3's subject, and the same record serves whichever
answer that step reaches.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01821k5B3Ysecp9fNYs92Kuy

src/scribe/mcp/server.py

@@ -185,6 +185,14 @@ _WRITE_TOOLS = frozenset({
     "create_rule", "create_project_rule", "update_rule", "move_rule", "delete_rule",
     "create_preference", "update_preference",
     "relate_rules", "unrelate_rules", "mark_rule_verified",
+    # rule_outcome writes only telemetry, which is the case _READ_ONLY_TOOLS
+    # above explicitly tolerates for getters that call record_pulled. It is
+    # classed as a WRITE anyway, on the difference that matters: those are
+    # reads that happen to leave a trace, while this tool's entire effect is
+    # the row — and the row carries `detail`, free prose the agent authored.
+    # A read-scoped key that can put text into the operator's database is not
+    # read-scoped, whatever table it lands in (#4212).
+    "rule_outcome",
     # retrieval tuning — a write in both senses: it moves the number the arm
     # reads, and it appends the reason to the audit trail (#4102).
     "tune_retrieval",